Tuesday, February 26, 2019
“Nick’s main attitude to east coast society is fascination.” How far, and in what ways do you agree with this statement?
In The Great Gatsby the liveings of the main book of factss atomic number 18 often difficult to work out, and this ambiguity continues with the character of snick. barely, I consider that the feeling of captivation could be fulfiln in two distinguish fitting rooms positive and negative. It could mean that break off is enthr exclusivelyed and entranced tout ensemble by what he sees, or hypnotised in that he is stupid(p) by how fake or shallow the people stick out be on the eastside slideway.Throughout the falsehood, scratchs thoughts and feelings change frequently, depending on the situation he is in and the people that he is with, and this is why it is difficult to try and wee-wee what his main feeling is as it varies so very such(prenominal). I will none at the main points in the book where the East Coast nine is clearly shown, and try to establish cuts main place and how Fitzgerald presents his thoughts and feelings to us. One of the capital places wher e Fitzgerald displays the hunting lodge to us is when prick meets Tom and Daisy.When describing Daisys voice, Nick enunciates vocalizes such as low, excite, and calls it an exhilarating ripple. I picture that this precedent of verbal description, which occurs frequently whenever Nick talks or so Daisy, show his captivation in a positive way with the East Coast world. The words thrilling and exhilarating imply that Nick is almost hypnotized by her as they atomic number 18 so emotive, something which I turn over holds true for the society as a whole it appears as if Nick is put in something of a trance by the captivate of it.I cogitate Fitzgerald chose Nick to contain this reaction to Daisy because it goes some way to showing his feelings towards the East Coast. This is because Fitzgerald leads the contributor to believe that Daisy is supposed to represent the people and the society on the east bank as a whole by making her pretty, somewhat fleeceable and somew hat false, Fitzgerald is able to show Nicks feelings active the situation as a whole through one character. I believe that this aspect of the impudent shows in the main the fascination on Nicks part.Although the indorser gets the supposition that Nick is mesmerized by this world, Fitzgerald sheds us doubt this due to the way that he has pen some of Nicks annals. For example, when describing Daisy and her mannerisms, Nick narrates That was a way she had. This quote implies that Nick palpableises that Daisy is not how she presents herself to be, and almost knows that shes fmelodic phrasely manipulative in the way she acts. There are numerous examples of this throughout Nick explains that Daisy has an absurd, charming little laugh, and the word absurd again implies that he finds it too charming to be real.I believe that Fitzgerald wanted Nicks feelings to be ambiguous these comments contribute to the postage stamp that if the reader takes away the surface attraction, Nick is actually fascinated by the faithlessness of the society round him rather than fascinated in wonder. In this way, I would say that Nicks main feeling here would besides be fascination but not in the same way as the fascination with Daisy and her appearance as I believe that to be more than of a surface fascination.Whilst I believe these negative comments to be a betoken of Nicks absorption in this world, it is easy to understand why some readers could take them as signs of out and out contempt. Contributing to this view would be the way that Fitzgerald makes Nick sound irritating and sometimes sarcastic towards Daisy. An example of this is when he says Thats why I came over tonight in response to Daisys move about the story of the butlers nose. The sarcasm is clearly evident in that reply, and it has an air of mockery to it also as the reader realises that Daisy is perhaps not the brightest of people.Fitzgerald has ensured that the reader knows that Nick has realised this also, and because of this, it would be easy to feel that he is mocking Daisy as he knows she wont understand the sarcasm in his response. This would take in the impression that Nick holds Daisy and the lifestyle in general in contempt and would consequently go against the avouchment that Nick is mainly fascinated by this world. However, I believe that many of Nicks sarcastic comments are actually him trying to be funny, as I dont believe that he would be capable of cosmos nasty to Daisy as he is so mesmerised by her.I also believe that this fits with Nicks perception of the whole society, due to the fact that I think Fitzgerald meant Daisy to represent the East Coast as a whole. another(prenominal) main situation in the novel where we see what Nick thinks about the society is up to and during Gatsbys parties. In a homogeneous fashion to his description of Daisy, at the beginning of Chapter 3 Nick provides us with a precise long description of everything about the parties.The description is very detailed, for example the spiced baked hams, crowded against salads of harlequin designs and pastry pigs and turkeys bewitched to a dark metallic. The detail in the description means that Fitzgerald has created the impression that Nick is tasting describing what he sees, and again that he is drawn in by the looseness and beauty of what he can see. This adds to this impression that Nicks main attitude. In growth to this, Fitzgerald uses lots words that make things sound magical in the description, for example bewitched, gold and floating.These words create the feeling in the readers minds that Nick is enchanted by what he is seeing as if he is placed in some diverseness of trance by the glamour of it all. Again, I believe that this can be consorted to how he feels about Daisy Nick is put in almost a trance by her looks and her voice, and its almost as if only the odd negative thought is able to slip through that. Again, Fitzgerald makes Nicks true feelings difficult to ascertain, as he puts in words into the description that are very ambiguous in their meaning.They make the reader unsure of Nicks truth in his words, as the way they are taken entirely depends on the individual readers point of view. An example of this is the phrase A bar with a real heart rail was right up. Here, the word real is what makes the reader unsure, as it could just be taken in the same way as everything else Nick is describing everything in sight with detail and relish. However, it could also be taken as mocking, because real sounds as if Nick could be making fun of those people who anxiety about and are truly fascinated by the authenticity of the brass rail.The first point of view, that this is genuine wonder from Nick, would contribute to the first interlingual rendition of fascination, as it would demonstrate a real interest in the frenzy of the society that they would be able to afford and expect something like that. However I believe that the sec ond point of view, the mockery, would also contribute to an attitude of fascination but the second interpretation of the word the meaning that involves Nick being fascinated by the shallowness and materialism of the people and the society in general.This is because the society in the East is a lot more concerned with possessions and appearances than Nick would have been used to in the Midwest, where family would have been much more important. In conclusion, in creating such intense description, I believe Fitzgerald makes the reader feel that Nicks main feeling here is fascination, but leaves us undecided as to what think. Another aspect of the parties that creates a similar predicament is how Fitzgerald creates dialogue and communion during the parties.When Nick is talking to the two girls, the way that the recitation during the dialogue between speech is put makes Nick sound potentially mocking the repetition, for example It was for Lucille, too sounds very mocking and as if Nick feels that the conversation he is surrounded by is very artificial and that zilch there is very individual. This would clearly be a reflection on society there as a whole and would go against the statement in the backing.Another possibility is that Fitzgerald wants the reader to feel that Nick feels shining to the people around him, and so is repeating names and sayings in gear up to create humour to be mocking in a more light-hearted way. This interpretation would not particularly support the view that Nick is fascinated by society either. However, another interpretation would be that Fitzgerald wants us to feel that Nick is so caught up in the conversation that he is exactly writing down everything because he feels it is all really interesting, or that he is too engrossed to filter what is being said.This third view of the narration by Fitzgerald would obviously support the statement that Nick is fascinated by the society. This is the view that I would take, due to the fact that other aspects placed in the novel at this point by Fitzgerald support it for example A thrill passed over all of us and We all turned and looked around for Gatsby. These sentences show that Fitzgerald wants us to see that Nick feels included in this conversation and is intrigued by it, and so adds to the view that Nicks main attitude is fascination.A similar effect is achieved by the way in which Fitzgerald structures the narration here when Nick is describing what he sees, he writes lists of the things. Fitzgerald has structured these not in a fluent, literary way but by putting a heavy repetition of the word and in-between each new addition to the list. This makes Nick seem almost overwhelmed by what he sees as if he is too mesmerised by it all to try and structure anything coherently.It also gives the reader the impression that the objects are never-ending, and makes us feel that Nick believes all the enthralling things he sees will go on forever. It creates the fee ling of wonder that I would intimacy strongly with fascination, and as a result I believe it supports the title statement. It could be pure fascination at the glamour and appearance of all these things, but it could also be fascination at just how much there is Nick could be in wonder at the too extravagant natures of the parties.Again, I believe Fitzgerald has constructed this ambiguity intentionally to show how Nick has conflicting emotions about the society he is now involved in. A separate place in the novel where we see Nick immersed in the East coast world is during his visit to fresh York, which we are soon told about. I believe Fitzgerald placed this description of New York in the novel to show Nicks reactions to the East Coast outside of East and West Egg.I think the description on New York adds to the idea that Nick is mainly fascinated by the society, because Fitzgerald uses such mysterious and magical words in the description for example enchanted, twilight and hau nting. These words create the feeling for the reader that Nick believes he is in some sort of magical world, and displays his obvious liking for the city. I think that Fitzgerald intended this to link with Nicks overall feelings about East and West Egg, as I believe that if he wished us to believe that Nick was repulsed by the nature of the range he would not be so complimentary about New York.The description creates an appealing vision of the city, not one that is meant to deter the reader. As a result, I believe that this description adds to the impression that Nicks main view is fascination. The way that Fitzgerald presents Nick also affects what we think his opinion is about East Coast society, because his constitution affects how we take his reactions. Fitzgerald has presented Nick as a character who always looks for glamour in situations, and prefers to see the better side of things.This can be seen in the New York description, when he imagines that he is involved in the liv es of the glamorous people around him. As a result of this personality we are given for Nick by Fitzgerald, personally I am more inclined to go with the interpretations that he is simply fascinated by what he sees of the culture in the East. In addition to this, we are told that Nick is very reserved with judgements, and this personality trait makes me think that Nick would because not be mocking and sarcastic so early on in the book i. . during the bits I have written about which also makes me believe that most of his fascination is genuine. Overall, I would agree fairly strongly with the statement that Nick is mainly fascinated by East Coast society however I think the type of fascination that he feels varies depending on the situation. I believe that he is fascinated in monetary value of the glamour of that world and also, at times, fascinated by how materialistic and shallow it appears to be.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment